Tier List

Fish A Pirate Pirate Tier List

Rarity-first rankings for crew slots, with mutated variants called out honestly as the meta shifts.

Last updated:

Pirate Tier List

This page ranks Fish A Pirate pirates by how hard they push money once placed on your crew. The loop is simple: fish chests, open pirates, place them for online and offline income, upgrade, then sail roughly 27 islands. Your tier choices decide how fast sail fees, slot unlocks, and the hourly world boss become affordable.

Exact cash-per-second figures move after Lucky Tide Studios patches, so this list uses relative bands from public gameplay rather than fake permanent DPS tables. Today that means Celestial pirates sit in S tier for raw money, Legendary pirates anchor A tier, mid rarities fill B, and commons live in C until you replace them. Mutated or aura-boosted versions of a rarity usually rank at the top of that rarity’s band—and can briefly punch above it—until a cleaner higher rarity lands.

For aura-only decisions, open the Mutations Tier List. For full crew recipes, use Best Crew. New players should skim Getting Started first, then return here whenever a chest or Legendary spin changes the board.

Ranking rules

  • Money after placement beats inventory flex and cosmetics.
  • Rarity ceiling matters: Celestial > Legendary > mid tiers > commons.
  • Mutations and auras multiply the pirate underneath; judge the pair, not the VFX alone.
  • Island context matters: a C-tier common can still be correct on island 2 and wrong on island 14.
  • Equip Best after every sail so outdated units leave premium slots.
  • Numbers are honest and provisional—reread after Admin Abuse floods or balance notes on the Updates Hub.

S tier — Celestial pirates

Celestial pirates are the current money ceiling. When a Celestial opens—especially with a strong mutation—free a crew slot immediately, place it, and dump upgrade cash into whatever multiplies that unit’s output. Celestials justify burning high-tier Luck potions, Legendary spins, and x999 Luck spins from codes or the Potion Guide.

Mutated Celestials sit at the absolute top of S. A clean Celestial still outranks almost every Legendary. Do not sell Celestials to “make space” unless your inventory is truly blocked and you already field multiple stronger mutated Celestials. On late islands, an S-tier crew is what funds Treasure’s End badge pacing and comfortable world-boss attempts.

During Admin Abuse events, free chests and admin luck can drop multiple Celestials in one sitting. Park potions before the window, open everything, then run Equip Best once—not after every single chest—so you compare final values cleanly.

A tier — Legendary pirates and top mutated mids

Legendary pirates are the workhorse rarity for mid and late progression. A full board of Legendaries carries you through expensive sails, extra slots, and the climb toward island 14 (Halfway badge) while you still hunt Celestials. Mutated Legendaries often sit at the high end of A and can temporarily rival a weak Celestial on a bad mutation roll—still replace them when a real Celestial arrives.

A tier also includes exceptional mutated versions of otherwise B-tier rarities when their aura multiplier is clearly elite. Keep those as bridge units: they earn their slot until Equip Best shows a strict upgrade. Spend Trait Tokens and Grade Tokens on A-tier keepers you expect to carry across several islands; avoid dumping tokens into pirates you already plan to sell after the next chest batch.

Legendary Spins from codes such as LAUNCH, GRANDTREASURE, LIKES250, and ADMINABUSE3 are best saved for sessions where you also drink Luck potions, so the spin and the chest luck stack. Pair this with Make Money Fast if you need upgrade order advice while A-tier units print cash.

B tier — Solid mid rarities

B-tier pirates are the respectable middles: strong enough to replace early commons, not strong enough to block a Legendary or Celestial. Use them to fill empty slots quickly after you sail, then graduate them out as better chests land. Mutated B-tier units can flirt with low A; clean B-tier units should not block inventory if you are flooded with Legendaries.

This band is also where many players waste Chest Speed potions. Faster chests help only if you are ready to evaluate and place results. If your board is already full of B fillers and you have no plan to Equip Best, slow down, sell weak duplicates, then reopen the throttle. Island sailing costs rise across the ~27-island route—see Islands and Sailing—so every B-to-A upgrade shortens the next fee grind.

C tier — Commons and early fillers

Commons, starter pulls, and low rares belong in C tier. They are correct during the tutorial badge and the first islands because empty slots earn nothing. They become wrong the moment you can field full B or A boards. Sell or reserve them without guilt.

C-tier traps to avoid:

  • Leaving tutorial pirates equipped after island 5+ because “they were there first.”
  • Spending Grade or Trait tokens on commons you will replace tonight.
  • Skipping Equip Best after a sail and wondering why income dipped.
  • Hoarding dozens of C duplicates instead of opening inventory for Legendary or Celestial hits.

Once you approach Halfway (island 14) and beyond, a C-tier unit on the board is almost always a mistake unless you literally have no other pirate. Endgame pressure toward Treasure’s End wants Celestials and mutated Legendaries, not nostalgia fillers.

Mutated variants versus clean rarities

Mutations and auras are ranked in detail on the mutations page, but pirate decisions still need a quick rule: rarity first, multiplier second. A mutated common rarely beats a clean Legendary for long. A mutated Legendary can beat a clean Celestial only while the Celestial’s own mutation is terrible—and even then you usually keep both until a better Celestial lands.

When two pirates share a rarity, keep the higher money ticker after a short placement test. Visual rarity text can lag behind actual income if an aura is doing heavy lifting. After Admin Abuse or a potion binge, retest your top six slots instead of trusting labels alone.

Practical swap checklist

  1. Open chests with Luck up if you are hunting S or A upgrades.
  2. Compare new pirates against the lowest earner currently placed.
  3. Place upgrades, then press Equip Best after sails or big hauls.
  4. Spend tokens only on pirates you will still field two islands from now.
  5. Recheck this list after patches posted on the Updates Hub.
  6. For team-wide layouts, follow Best Crew rather than forcing six identical Celestials if slots or pulls are not there yet.

How this list stays honest

We will not invent permanent DPS spreadsheets that go stale in a week. When Lucky Tide retunes Celestial income, Legendary odds, or mutation multipliers, relative order matters more than last week’s screenshot. If a community claim conflicts with live money tickers, trust the ticker, note the patch, and adjust the band.

Combine this tier list with the Players Hub for roster vocabulary, Scripts only after reading safety notes, and the Tools Hub when you need potion timing. Strong pirates plus disciplined swaps beat random chest spam every time.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers to the most common Fish A Pirate questions.

Is Celestial always better than Legendary in Fish A Pirate?

Almost always for money. A mutated Legendary can briefly compete with a poorly mutated Celestial, but a solid Celestial should take a slot as soon as you pull one.

Should I sell all common pirates?

Sell or replace commons once you can fill the board with B-tier or better. Keep them only while empty slots would otherwise earn nothing on early islands.

Do mutated pirates get their own tier?

Mutated versions sit at the top of their rarity band and can edge into the band above. For aura-only rankings, use the mutations tier list.

Why did Equip Best remove my favorite pirate?

Equip Best sorts by current value, not favorites. If a unit left the board, a higher earner took the slot—check the money ticker before forcing it back.

How often should I reread this pirate tier list?

After major updates, Admin Abuse floods, or any patch that changes Celestial or Legendary income. Relative bands shift even when rarity names stay the same.